Thursday, April 9, 2026

Peter's Transformation (Reflections on Easter 2, 2026)


Although you have not seen him, you love him, and even though you do not see him now, you believe in him and rejoice with an indescribable and glorious joy, for you are receiving the outcome of your faith, the salvation of your souls. (1 Peter 1:8-9)

It’s something of a tradition that the gospel passage we get for Easter 2 in the Revised Common Lectionary is always this story of “Doubting Thomas (John 20:19-31).” Smart Bible scholar folks have a theory about this. Without getting too much into the historical/literary critical weeds, let’s just say that around the end of the first century of the Common Era there may have been a little rivalry between the disciples of John and the disciples of Thomas. Subsequently, when John’s disciple writes his resurrection narrative, he makes Thomas look like a doofus for not taking his buddies’ word that Jesus really is raised from the dead[i]. 

(Of course, if the Johannine account is correct, you can hardly blame Thomas for being a little skeptical. It’s not like people get raised from the dead every day! But I digress.)

Yes, poor Thomas looks like a doubting, faithless doofus in John’s gospel. He, therefore, stands in stark contrast to Peter, who looks like a doofus in all four gospels. I mean, how would you like it if the one thing everyone remembered about you was the fact you shot your big pie hole off about being faithful to Jesus even unto death, and then—the second things got a little uneasy—you denied you even knew the guy? And not once, but three times?

But the Peter we meet on Easter 2 isn’t the same guy we saw on Good Friday. Somehow a switch got flipped, and the old, cowardly, say-it-before-you-thought-about-it Peter has given way to the bold and eloquent messenger of the Gospel we meet in our first reading (Acts 2:14a, 22-32).

I’d hate to have been Good Friday Peter, wouldn’t you? The guy must’ve been feeling a boatload of emotions, and none of them were good. In a braggadocio moment the night before he swore he’d stand by Jesus even if he had to die for him. He was ready to draw his sword and do battle to protect his rabbi, but when the temple police slapped the cuffs on Jesus, Peter ran away like the others. Then he denied he was Jesus’ disciple. I don’t think this was calculated. I think fear just oozed out of him before he knew what he was saying.

The gospels tell us Peter wept bitterly that night. I imagine him slumped in some dark, dirty corner of  Jerusalem ally, his head between his knees, his body heaving with sobs. What were those tears about? Shame and self-loathing when a man sees himself as being weak and cowardly? Disgust at his own hypocrisy? Grief for the certain death of the friend, teacher, and leader whom he so dearly loved? Utter despair and disillusionment for the movement which promised to be about joy and liberation, but which has turned out to be about nothing at all?

But then came Easter. Peter encountered the risen Jesus and something in him was resurrected too. Peter became like an addict who has conquered addiction. Like a woman escaping an abusive partner. Like a bankrupt starting over. Like a hostage set free. In the power of Christ’s resurrection, he shed the demons of fear, shame, guilt, and self-doubt and became the rock Jesus had prophesied he’d become. He’d become a real adult—whatever his chronological age might’ve been at that moment.

It’s believed he eventually left Judea and Galilee to share the joy he found in Jesus around the Mediterranean world. His journey took him to Antioch in Syria, across the sea to Corinth in Greece, and finally to Rome.

By the time the epistle we call 1 Peter was written (probably sometime in the late 90’s of the Common Era), Peter would be dead. It’s doubtful the Galilean fisherman could write in such sophisticated Greek, so the letter was probably composed by a disciple who had known Peter in Rome.

The letter would’ve been written to that Roman church, and I’m sure that congregation could relate to Peter’s story. Some of them may have lived through the Great Fire of 64 CE and seen everything they owned destroyed. They may have known the terror of flaming death all around them with no place to run, escaping only by crawling through the sewer. They certainly knew the grief of losing beloved leaders as both Peter and Paul would be executed by the imperial authorities. They also knew disappointment as they waited for Jesus’ return and Jesus appeared to be taking his good, sweet time about coming back. Worst of all, they were living under persecution for their faith, marginalized and even criminalized for loving the Savior they’d never met in the flesh.

But through all of this, they received the outcome of their faith just as their leader Peter had done. Some may have been peasants, and some were even slaves, but they loved Jesus and knew Jesus loved them. In turn, they could love one another. They could rejoice even in their suffering because the earthly authorities which took Peter from them could not take away their baptism, their love, or their hope.

What is the outcome of our faith? I like to think it’s real maturity—a maturity which leads us to be like those early Christians who so resonated with Peter’s story. We are to be a community of love; forgiveness for ourselves and others; courage in the face of chaos, doubt, and uncertainty; selflessness; and, finally, peace.

May your faith bring you to that peace, my friend. Thanks for visiting my blog this week.

 



[i] If you’d like to learn more about this, I suggest you check out Elaine Pagel’s wonderful book Beyond Belief: The Secret Gospel of Thomas (New York: Random House, 2003)

No comments:

Post a Comment