Tuesday, July 22, 2025

Frustrating Prayers (Reflection on Pentecost 7, Year C 2025)

 


“So I say to you, Ask, and it will be given to you; search, and you will find; knock, and the door will be opened for you. (Luke 11:9)

Yup. All you have to do is ask. But here’s where the Bible gives us grief: What happens when you ask and you don’t, receive, seek and don’t find, knock and the person on the other side of the door tells you to get lost? The Gospel lesson for Pentecost 7, Year C (Luke 11: 1-13) is potentially a faith-annihilating scripture for anyone who has been praying their butt off when God doesn’t seem to be listening.

The lesson starts with the disciples asking Jesus to teach them to pray. After all, John the Baptist taught his disciples. Now, you’d think the act of prayer wouldn’t require an instruction manual, but I guess in the world of this text folks were so used to formal prayers led by priests or rabbis that they were afraid they’d mess it up if they just tried to do it on their own. Jesus gives them some pretty good advice about what to pray for. Unfortunately, if you think about it too hard, even these simple supplications don’t look like anything God’s in a big hurry to grant.

Check it out: We’re told to ask God to make his name holy to us, but we’re seldom open to observing or remembering the sacred. We ask God to send God’s kingdom—God’s rule of righteousness, peace, and love—but we’re still living in a kingdom of our own making (which pretty much sucks!). We ask for our daily bread, but folks are still going hungry. We ask to have our sins[i] forgiven just as we forgive those indebted to us[ii]. We might be in real trouble with this one. Finally, we ask not to be put to the test when we live in a world of violence, inflation, climate change, sickness, political polarization, and a bunch of dumbasses who get on our last nerves. If God answers prayer, shouldn’t we get a break from all of this?

The clever fellows who cooked up the Revised Common Lectionary decided to stick this lesson Jesus gives us about praying for stuff we don’t seem to be getting with a continuation of last week’s story from Genesis (Genesis 18:20-32). Here Abraham is bargaining with God like a gringo tourist dickering with a Tijuana street vendor. God’s told Abraham he’s going to Sodom to open a giant can of holy wrath on the godless miscreants who live there—who, by the way, really deserve to get their asses kicked. This is an issue for Abraham since his nephew Lot and Lot’s family are residents of Sodom. He doesn’t want God to wipe out family members, so he enters into this negotiation—careful to be respectful and not piss God off—in order to save Lot. Abrahm essentially slaps God with one of the most challenging of all moral conundrums: which is the bigger sin—letting the guilty get away with their evil or punishing the innocent?

(We know which choice the Israeli government is making today. They’d happily drop bombs and kill 99 innocent Gazan civilians if it meant killing one Hamas terrorist. I think the Bible suggests just the opposite. But I digress.)

Spoiler alert: Abraham’s prayer for mercy goes unanswered. God can’t seem to find ten righteous people in all of Sodom, so he lets Lot and family escape and then nukes the whole town.[iii] I think Abraham showed himself to be a pretty good guy here, praying for mercy for people who didn’t deserve it. Nevertheless, this was an unanswered prayer. Perhaps the effect the prayer had on the people of Sodom was less important in God’s eyes than the effect it had on Abraham for praying it. Maybe the crucial thing was the very act of prayer, the attempt to connect with God and the compassion needed to reach out for others. Perhaps this is what God really wanted. This makes me wonder if, perhaps, God really did answer Abraham’s prayer, just not in the way Abraham expected it.

All of this gets me thinking about my own prayer life. Yeah, I do all the liturgical prayers on Sunday, and I pray at church council meetings and when I make pastoral care calls. Still, I find I might be neglecting my own personal prayer time. When I do pray, it’s usually because I need to ask God for a personal favor or I need to make intercession for somebody. Sometimes I ask for guidance, wisdom, and advice which doesn’t look like it’s forthcoming. I don’t often stop and thank God for being God or ask that I might be open to seeing the holy around me.

There’s this one intercessory prayer I shoot up almost every day on my drive to work. I drive past the Sacred Heart Cemetery in Mt. Holly, New Jersey where, some years ago, I laid to rest two sisters who were brutally murdered. When I spoke with their parents before their funeral and felt the overwhelming, crushing nature of their grief, I knew there was absolutely nothing I would ever say that would ease their pain or take away the torment of their loss. I pray for those two bereaved people every time I pass that cemetery. I pray God will grant them peace—a peace I know they may never feel. Yet I pray for it anyway. I keep wondering if these prayers of mine are changing me even if they’re not changing circumstances.

The only thing Jesus tells us the Father will give is the Holy Spirit, and maybe that’s what we really need after all. The world will not change unless we change. So, we keep on praying and asking in faith believing—in the immortal words of Mick Jagger—you can’t always get what you want, but if you try some time, you might find you get what you need.

Want to feel the Holy Spirit? Keep praying.

I will send up a few prayers for YOU, Dear Reader, and I hope you come and visit me again.

 


[i] The Greek here is hamartias emon which means our “missing the mark” or “falling short.” It doesn’t necessarily mean our willful disobedience to God’s law. It means our nature of being total screw-ups.

[ii] The Greek here is panti opheilanti hemin. It is translated literally in the New Revised Standard Version as “everyone indebted to us.” This means those who owe us money are to have their debts forgiven just as we are to forgive those who may have wronged us. Trough ask, don’t you think?

[iii] See Genesis 19: 24. Actually, things didn’t work out that well for Lot and Company either. His wife was turned to a pillar of salt. As for the rest of the story (Genesis 19:30-37) you really don’t want to know. Trust me.

No comments:

Post a Comment