Sunday, December 17, 2023

The Gospel According to Scrooge (Reflections on the Nativity of Our Lord, 2023)

 
“Glory to God in the highest heaven, and on earth peace among those whom he favors.” (Luke 2:14)

“Bah, humbug!”

That phrase is almost as ubiquitous as “Merry Christmas.” It’s the grouchy epithet spewed out of the snarled lips of the greatest miser in literary history, Ebenezer Scrooge. With the singular exception of the story of Our Lord’s nativity, Charles Dickens’ ghostly yarn, A Christmas Carol, the story of the lonely, covetous, ill-tempered capitalist is probably my favorite Christmas story—and, possibly, one of  my favorite stories in all English literature.

I first encountered A Christmas Carol in junior high, and I guess I’ve seen every movie version of it ever made and quite a few stage adaptations. I played the role of Scrooge myself when I was in high school. I remembered I had about a half pound of greasepaint[i] on my face to create Scrooges hollows and frown lines, and my hair was sprayed white. Decades later I played the role again in a charity production for our Lutheran Social Ministry Organization Feast of Justice. By that time I didn’t need the greasepaint or the white spray.

Dickens wrote his Christmas novella in 1843just as England was experiencing something of a renaissance in the observance of Christmas. Hitherto, Christmas was just another Christian feast day observed in the Anglican Church like Epiphany and Pentecost. Its more festive aspects were mostly observed in rural communities; however, with the German influence of Prince Albert on Queen Victoria, it was becoming a “thing” with the more fashion-conscious Brits.

The juxtaposition of greed and poverty was a pretty big deal for Charles Dickens. As a child he experienced considerable hardship and degradation. When his father was chucked in prison for non-payment of debt, twelve-year-old Charles was forced to sell his library of books and go to work in a factory putting labels on bottles of shoe polish. It was a penurious and humiliating experience he never forgot. Even after experiencing some success as a writer, Dickens never lost his concern for the poor. Earlier in 1843 he toured Cornish tin mines and witnessed the deplorable condition of child laborers. He also was given a tour of The Ragged School, a virtual penitentiary masquerading as an educational institution for London’s street urchins.

His response was to write the classic tale of the selfish man who, through supernatural intervention, is forced to see the error of his ways and opens his heart to the less fortunate. As a novelist and magazine editor, Dickens would annually produce a Christmas story, but none of his subsequent works ever had the power over the public imagination as did A Christmas Carol. Dickens was not a particularly religious man, but the story of Scrooge’s conversion resonates deeply with the teachings of our faith.

Chiefly, the tale is about the possibilities of redemption and forgiveness. As Scrooge recognizes the depth of his own sin, he asks the Spirit of Christmas Yet to Come, “Are these the shadows of things that will be, or are they the shadows of things that may be only? Men’s courses will foreshadow certain ends, to which, if they be persevered in, they must lead. But if the courses be departed from, the ends will change.”

What always strikes me about this scene of Scrooge’s self-realization is that he would not have come to it without intervention—just as we, without the promptings of the Holy Spirit, would not come back to our own need for repentance. I like to believe that God’s spirit had something to do with Dickens in inspiring him to write this tale. After A Christmas Carol was published charitable giving in Britain increased dramatically. Many attributed this to the book’s influence. Indeed, from that time to this, charity to the poor has become as much a Christmas tradition as mistletoe, colored lights, and candy canes.

But Christians know that the gospel story has always been more about poverty than opulence, and more about oppression than privilege. In Luke’s gospel it’s a distant and uncaring government which forces a man and his pregnant fiancé on a dangerous 70-mile journey from Nazareth to Bethlehem. The mother of our Lord and Savior is an unmarried, pregnant teenager. She will give birth in a barn—homeless and left outside. The birth of the Christ will be announced to a group of peasants. In Matthew’s gospel, the child and his parents will soon become refugees, forced to run from their native land and seek refuge in a foreign country.

Above all, we know that the Christmas story is about God coming to us. We are, as the song says, “in sin and error pining ‘til he appeared and the soul felt its worth.” Not the worth of our own estimation, but our worth in God’s eyes—in the eyes of the one who came to us so we could see his power, love, and majesty in a small, helpless baby.

May we, like dear old Scrooge, have our hearts continually moved by the homeless infant in the animal’s feeding trough. May we daily die to sin and rise to newness of life.

And may God bless us, every one!



[i] Yes, greasepaint. It was still used back then—a particularly nasty petroleum-based make-up designed over a century ago by Max Factor. It covered your skin like Sherwin Williams paint and took forever to wash off. Ah, the things I did for my art!

No comments:

Post a Comment